What, Me Worried?! A Metrics of Stress Case Study

Alfred_E._Neumann

Last week a client of mine came in whose numbers were seemingly inexplicably up.  I hadn’t seen him for quite a while and since he is usually 6-7% body fat it, he was quite dismayed by the numbers which had popped up to 12%.  He said he’d been eating the same and exercising as always and couldn’t understand how he could be up.  So I asked him what had been going on since I’d last seen him and he told me he was finalizing his divorce.  This on top of his day gig of running a billion-dollar private equity firm.  I gently suggested that his numbers may be attributable to stress.  “What?!” he snapped.  “I’m NOT STRESSED!”  Umm, okay, if you say so…”

I explained to him that with skinfold calipers, we can get inflated numbers because when we’re stressed the adrenals are overworked.  The adrenals maintain fluid balance so when they’re doing overtime we end up with some edema.  Of course, if stress is chronic, elevated cortisol also contributes to accumulation of body fat as well.

Some people handle their stress very well but may not be aware of how it’s affecting them physiologically.  This is where metrics can be invaluable for showing a client where he/she’s at and can be the factor in motivating them to change their behavior.

Kathy's Chart

My client Kathy is an excellent example of how important metrics can be.  If we take a look at her body composition chart you’ll see she made great progress but not without a few blips along the way.  This is real life.  But what’s so fantastic about Kathy is that she tracked all her food and exercise, and she wore a FitBit all day.  Since she was following everything to the letter most of the time, if one variable was out of whack, we were able to isolate it as the culprit.

So on Kathy’s chart we can see she was doing fine until Week 5 when her menstrual cycle showed up.  This is pretty common and will affect body composition due to water retention from increased inflammation.  It’s interesting to note that this was not a factor for the rest of her chart.  This isn’t surprising since one of the benefits of getting blood sugars under control is reduced inflammation, which in turn will reduce premenstrual symptoms.  We also see blips in weeks 21-24 due to overtraining, which is a subject we’ll address in another entry.

Of more interest for our discussion of psychological stress, however, are Weeks 11-15.   Kathy had done amazingly well, plummeting from 29% to almost 12% body fat.  Until the month of April killed us and she popped up as high as 17%.  Why?  Well, a job opportunity came up that Kathy really wanted.  She really, really, really wanted this gig.  And in April the interview process started.  A lot of people don’t believe me when I say stress may be the cause of elevated “body fat” numbers—whether from actual body fat or water retention.  But in this case, we had some amazing data because Kathy was wearing a FitBit the whole time.  So I asked her for some random screen captures of her heart rate during those weeks.

 

You can see that April 7 is our baseline day before she found out about this job opportunity.  Her heart rate throughout the day never really peaks past 100 until her evening exercise class where she topped out in the 130’s.  The second week her heart rate (not counting the evening exercise elevation) spikes past 100 twice and BPM’s are closer to 100 throughout the day.  The third week—and she’s in the thick of the interview process by now—heart rate spikes past 100 4 times and a little higher between spikes as well.  The fourth screenshot she surpasses 100 BPM 5 times and heartrate is considerably elevated between spikes.  And the fifth screen shot is the day of the final interview.  Her heart rate is almost 150 while NOT exercising!

KathyFitBit1
Baseline Heart rate under 100 except during exercise in the evening.
KathyFitBit2
Kathy just found out about job opportunity. Heart rate starting to peak past 100 during the day.
KathyFitBit3
Job interview process has started. Heart rate spiking past 100 at more points.
KathyFitBit4
Well into the interview process.
KathyFitBit5
Final interview. Heart rate is almost 150 during the actual interview!

This story, at least, has a happy ending.  Kathy got the job and she made a full body composition recovery two weeks after.  I was thrilled that she had the metrics for the month because they show:

  • That even GOOD stress (she really wanted that job!) can still affect the body adversely. Over-stimulation of the sympathetic nervous system still taxes the adrenals.  Sometimes clients say they are stress-free because it’s not negative stress as we’ve just seen, eustress—good stuff—still has a physiological effect.

 

  • Over stimulation of the sympathetic nervous system (stress) really does affect you physically! And skinfold calipers, though old school, are a great way to observe the adverse effects stress can have on your body composition.  Wild fluctuations in body comp can indicate fluid imbalance due to adrenal and lymphatic overload.

Just telling my clients that stress will make them fat or, in the short term, appear so is often too abstract for them to prompt behavioral changes.  They’ve heard stress does these things to the body—“yeah, yeah, yeah.”  But metrics make all of this tangible.  With a few simple tools—a heart rate monitor and caliper measurements–you can observe the effects of sympathetic nervous system overdrive on the body.  Simple metrics can be a great motivator to make big lifestyle changes.

kathy
Story with a happy ending: Kathy at her new job!